Device uses movement of ions to generate airflow without any moving parts like in iPads and MacBook Air.
Counterpoint: stop trying to make laptops thinner and implement realistic and functional air cooling
Passive cooling is generally better for reliability if you can make it work, since all active airflow systems will degrade as dust and hair works into the airflow paths.
Plus, the two can be used in combination. Improved passive cooling systems will make active cooling better by reducing the need to run the active system all the time, or at least run it at reduced rates, which will make the whole system last longer and reduce maintenance.
Or we innovate 🤷
It isn’t a given that every device needs a fan anymore. For example non intel MacBook air.
Speaking from experience here, and limited information from the company, this looks like a polished version of a high-voltage grid accelerator.
https://ventiva.com/how-it-works/
What can be an expected concern is that besides ionizing air and imparting motion to neutral air molecules as the ionized ones rush from one plate to the other, that same effect can and will charge dust particles. That “collector plate” will need to be easily accessible.
Appreciate the link. I’ve got a hand-me-down Ionic in my house, and knowing that I can skip running it for basically the same effect means I can save a couple of cents on my electricity bill.
Gonna take another look at those IKEA tables with the HEPA filters built in. Those seem handy to avoid having to dust so often.
Sure thing, glad to be of some kinda help. Ozone can be a good irritant, never mind charged dust sticking to stuff it ordinarily wouldn’t.
I hope this company has a trick for dust control, but I’m expecting that’d be tougher than figuring out the ionic wind part.
I have a house filter that functions on the same principal… Lol!
Hey! Are you crazy!!! You’re wearing pants while using your new iPad? Those pants club iPads in mere seconds! Try new silicone pants! Silicone pants are as clean as polystyrene without the downsides of other clean fabrics such as glass fabric! Get them at Walmart! Or get a new IPad Thin! It comes with a clean set including underwear, hair removal creme, pants, T-shirt and panties and bra for women. You can get a discount if you don’t want the unisex version. The I-condom comes included with Bluetooth.
I think Dave2D made a video about those. He was cautiously optimistic.
Ionic acceleration of air needs high voltages and the air gets ionized (the reason people recommend against vacuuming a PC). I’m surprised that it works at all in close proximity to sensible tech.
Edit: right, low static pressure, meaning: lower voltages. But still not low.
They use a grounded faraday cage around it. Video on it where he touched on that https://youtu.be/fyai_kUYhLs
Can’t watch the video rn, anything about the dust problem?
He just mentions they have a solution but it’s patented so they wouldn’t talk about it. Take that as you will of course
Strange, patented means it should be findable on the USPTO system, diagrams and all. And yet…
Is this the same way those bladeless Dyson fans work?
Those things have a fan with blades, just stuck in the base.
They aren’t actually bladeless. The fan is just hidden in the base.
Bladeless Dyson’s have the fans hidden, as far as I know. But they still have a bladed fan in there.
Yes but they generate more airflow than the fan alone can
They do not. For a given power input they produce less airflow at lower velocity than a regular fan. They’re a complete scam.
Citation needed
I recently watched some YouTube video that debunked that claim. They are basically pointless.
Edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ySSo5PmZZJM
It actually works better when You take the inner fan out of the casing. So they are actually a scam.
Not a dyson
Not a proper test, air volume not measured - only speed. The point is to not have fast air so this only confirms the concept works
They literally generate as much as that small fan in the case can generate.
With the aerodynamics of the case it’s just a matter of converting higher pressure into lower pressure with higher (& a bit more laminated) airflow.
I think you are talking about the Coandă effect.
I believe it’s called entrainment which is different?
More like those Ionic Breeze air purifiers.
I see what they did there with the “ICE9” name.
If it works, it sounds like it’d be something meant for a future Steam Deck to experiment with.
Sadly, this won’t go anywhere now for the same reason it didn’t go anywhere for the 10 times it has been proposed before. It looks great on first look but longevity is amazingly low and likely will require purchasing of catalyst less than a year after first use. I’m sure investors loved that part of the pitch but compared to current fan tech, with good static pressure, there’s no way someone with half a brain would chuck this in their laptop. And that’s before considering the rest of the downsides.
What catalyst? There’s no chemical process here.
Manganese dioxide is used to decompose ozone. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1001074222005083
Highly suspect this account is part of some kind of influencer marketing bundle. On lemmy, such amount of upvotes for a completely wrong post is unusual given the population around here.
It uses an MnO2 catalyst plus a non disclosed tech which will absolutely not last a year if the laptop is used for anything more than web browsing or happens to be used, you know, on your lap.
Looking forward to be wrong on this one, except, I won’t.
Oh, to compensate for generated ozone. I suppose that would depend on how quickly it’s depleted.
Possibly to deal with the ozone things like this can produce.
Uuuh, the cooling in macbook airs and ipads is just passive aircooling, like in all phones and all other “normal” tablets.
Well passive heat exchanger works as long as your device doesn’t have big power/TDP on it like office laptop, mobile phone, etc.
There’s no rule against using active cooling for tablets and phones, only practicality. This technology seems like it might be practical enough to use in compact devices such as those, but we’ll see if that’s true.
I’d be surprised if they can keep phones with this waterproof and dust proof. Laptops I can see, phones not so much.
Yeah I can only see this being used as an external phone cooler or maybe for niche ‘gaming phones’ that would otherwise have a fan